Complete the indicated task in Story mode to unlock the corresponding character in Exhibition mode.
Black Machismo: Defeat Black Machismo.
Brother Ray: Defeat Team 3D.
Eric Young: After getting partnered with Eric Young, win a Tag Team match with him.
Jay Lethal: Defeat Jay Lethal in your TNA Tryout Gauntlet match.
Moves for your created superstar: Various moves are unlocked as your progress through story mode.