Completing each preset Custom Night game mode will unlock toys that are placed on the desk in the office. Stars will appear on the main menu.
| Unlockable | How to unlock
|
|---|
| BB doll | Complete Night of Misfits in the Custom Night.
|
| Bonnie doll | Complete Double Trouble in the Custom Night.
|
| Chica doll | Complete Ladies Night in the Custom Night.
|
| Cupcake plushie | Complete Cupcake Challenge in the Custom Night.
|
| Foxy doll | Complete Foxy Foxy in the Custom Night.
|
| Freddy Fazbear doll | Complete Freddy's Circus in the Custom Night.
|
| Gold star #1 | Complete the 5th night.
|
| Gold star #2 | Complete the 6th night.
|
| Gold star #3 | Complete 20/20/20/20 in the Custom Night.
|
| Golden Freddy doll | Complete Golden Freddy in the Custom Night.
|
| Microphone | Complete Fazbear Fever in the Custom Night.
|
| Toy Bonnie figurine | Complete New & Shiny in the Custom Night.
|
