| Achievement | How to unlock | Points
|
|---|
| ... And I Can Not Lie (secret) | Complete the secret game | 50
|
| A Bridge Two Fear (secret) | Survive the twins on the bridge | 20
|
| Claustrophobia (secret) | Survive being trapped in the shack with Thomas | 20
|
| Collection A | Find all collectibles for hour one | 20
|
| Collection B | Find all collectibles for hour two | 20
|
| Collection C | Find all collectibles for hour three | 20
|
| Collection D | Find all collectibles for hour four | 20
|
| Collection E | Find all collectibles for hour five | 20
|
| Dig THIS! (secret) | Survive Caleb after he surfaces | 20
|
| Epilogue (secret) | Survive the Epilogue | 50
|
| Everyone Dies | Die in the first hour | 10
|
| Fifth Hour | Survive Hour Five | 20
|
| First Hour | Survive Hour One | 10
|
| Fourth Hour | Survive Hour Four | 20
|
| Go Back To Sleep (secret) | Survive Benny after he wakes up. | 20
|
| Hangin' Out With Dad | Encounter John Weaver | 20
|
| Hidden in the Darkness | Unlock the secret game | 50
|
| Hide 'n' Seek | Survive Lillian's game | 20
|
| Laid to Rest... (secret) | Deliver all lost items | 50
|
| Last Year... | Find what is lost | 50
|
| Lights On | Survive an hour without any darkness | 20
|
| Matchstick Man | Survive an hour with only using matches | 20
|
| Mommy Dearest | Encounter Mary Weaver | 20
|
| Nevermore | Shoo the stupid bird seven times | 20
|
| No Way Out (secret) | Complete the prequel | 50
|
| Reveal the Truth... (secret) | Unlock the epilogue | 50
|
| Schooled! (secret) | Survive encountering Tim on the school bus | 20
|
| Second Hour | Survive Hour Two | 10
|
| Sunday Worship | Go to church | 20
|
| The Rock of "Nope" (secret) | Survive encountering Lillian at the large rock | 20
|
| Third Hour | Survive Hour Three | 20
|
| This One Time, at Wick Camp... | Explore all of Pine Creek camp | 20
|
| Toasty! | Witness the house burn down | 20
|
| True Detective | Collect all evidence | 20
|
| We're Gonna Need A Bigger Fridge | Collect all drawings | 20
|
| Well well well... | Have three candles on the Well at the same time | 20
|
| Wicked (secret) | 100% complete the game | 100
|
