| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Bill's Story | Finish the game with Bill | Bronze
|
| Bob's Story | Finish the game with Bob | Bronze
|
| Brandon's Story | Finish the game with Brandon | Bronze
|
| But Why? (secret) | Shoot a horse. | Bronze
|
| Charles's Story | Finish the game with Charles | Bronze
|
| Harry's Story | Finish the game with Harry | Bronze
|
| Jesse's Story | Finish the game with Jesse | Bronze
|
| Marc's Story | Finish the game with Marc | Bronze
|
| Matthew's Story | Finish the game with Matthew | Bronze
|
| Old Friend's Story | Finish the game with an old friend | Bronze
|
| Sociopath | Finish the game alone | Bronze
|
| Soldier's Story | Finish the game with a soldier | Bronze
|
| Thomas's Story | Finish the game with Thomas | Bronze
|
