| Achievement | How to Unlock |
| A Cut Above (20 points) | Get the highest overall approval Rating in the league, after one season
|
| Best Ever (250 points) | Win the Super Bowl 3 times with the same team
|
| Best of all Time (100 points) | Go undefeated during a season
|
| Drawing Some Plays in the Dirt (10 points) | Create at least 10 custom plays
|
| Gameday Guru (50 points) | Complete a head to head match on Xbox LIVE
|
| Goal Oriented (15 points) | Accomplish all of your Season Goals
|
| Gold Miner (10 points) | Find 90+ Potential Training Camp Invite
|
| I'm The Decider (10 points) | Get 100 percent correct defining moments during a game day
|
| Man of the People (10 points) | Get your approval level with your team's players to 80, after one season
|
| Media Darling (10 points) | Get your approval level with the media to 80, after one season
|
| Mr Popularity (10 points) | Get your approval level with the fans to 80, after one season
|
| Nerves of Steel (10 points) | Successful Defining Moments 20+
|
| One Big Happy Family (10 points) | Get your approval level with your coaching staff to 80
|
| One for the Mantle (50 points) | Win the Coach of the Year award, after one season
|
| Repeat Offender (100 points) | Win back to back Super Bowls with one team
|
| Teachers Pet (10 points) | Get your approval level with your owner to 80, after one season
|
| We Idolize You (75 points) | Get an overall Approval Rating of 95, after one season
|
| We Like You (25 points) | Get an overall Approval Rating of 85, after one season
|
| We Love You (50 points) | Get an overall Approval Rating of 90, after one season
|
| Welcome to the Club (125 points) | Win 100 games with a created coach
|
| Xs and Os Guy (20 points) | Create at least 25 custom plays
|
| You Arrived (30 points) | Win your first Super Bowl ring
|
